SpriteForge.tech
Play the demo Blog Pricing Open the studio

PixelLab vs Retro Diffusion vs SpriteForge: the same game, three art sets

← All posts · · 5 min read · video
TL;DR
  • The test: 15 sprites, a walk animation and a ground tile set for a top-down survivors-like game, on all three services, using the highest quality option on each.
  • The sprites: SpriteForge's are cleaner and less noisy, and to me they look more like something a person made. Across all 15 it used 78 colours. Retro Diffusion used 396 and PixelLab 256.
  • The cost: here SpriteForge clearly loses. The numbers are in the table.
  • The result: not the landslide victory for SpriteForge I was hoping for. It's a mixed bag.

I'm comparing PixelLab, Retro Diffusion and SpriteForge, by making the same game in each.

Disclosure: SpriteForge is my service, but I will try to be as impartial as possible.

This post is the written version of the video. Watch it on YouTube.

How the three work

For those who don't know: PixelLab and Retro Diffusion are, to my knowledge, the two most popular AI pixel art services.

They use pixel art LoRAs to fine-tune diffusion models, so the output mimics the look of pixel art. That closeness to pixel art makes snapping the output to a grid, and its colours to a palette, somewhat effective.

SpriteForge works differently. It uses LLMs like Claude to draw the pixel art. Nothing has to be snapped to a grid, because it is already pixel art by construction. And the model can be given the palette up front, so it only draws with those colours.

They work differently, but the goal is the same: pixel art you can actually use in a game.

The test

For this comparison I generated 15 sprites, a walk animation and a ground tile set, for a top-down survivors-like game, on all three services, using the highest quality option on each.

Almost everything is 16×16. The boss and the tree are 32×32.

The sizes in the test, in three columns for SpriteForge, Retro Diffusion and PixelLab: a purple slime at 16 by 16 (most sprites), the stag boss at 32 by 32 and the pine tree at 32 by 32
The sizes. Columns, left to right: SpriteForge, Retro Diffusion, PixelLab.

1. The sprites

First comparison: the individual sprites. Let's go through them.

The ranger. All three are readable. SpriteForge's is the simplest, with flat, clean colours. The other two pack in more detail than 16 pixels can really hold.

The ranger from each tool, with its colours laid out underneath. SpriteForge: a ranger in a wide tan hat, an orange scarf and a green tunic, in flat colours, 16 colours. Retro Diffusion: a darker ranger in an olive hat with a heavy black outline, 35 colours. PixelLab: a narrow figure in a brown hat with a red scarf, 27 colours
The ranger, 16×16. Left to right: SpriteForge (16 colours), Retro Diffusion (35), PixelLab (27).

The slime and the bat. On dark ground, SpriteForge's read at a glance. The diffusion ones are darker and muddier, which is what tends to happen at this size.

The slime and the bat from each tool on dark ground. SpriteForge: a round purple slime with yellow eyes and a bat with pale wings and red eyes. Retro Diffusion: a small dull purple slime and a grey-blue bat. PixelLab: a dark purple slime with orange eyes and a grey and purple bat
The slime and the bat, 16×16. Columns, left to right: SpriteForge, Retro Diffusion, PixelLab.

The wolf. SpriteForge wins here clearly. The PixelLab and Retro Diffusion wolves are really messy and lack any clear features.

The wolf from each tool. SpriteForge: a wolf seen from the front, grey-blue with cyan eyes and a pale muzzle, 11 colours. Retro Diffusion: a grey-teal four-legged shape in a dark outline, 35 colours. PixelLab: a dark blue four-legged shape, 25 colours
The wolf, 16×16. Left to right: SpriteForge (11 colours), Retro Diffusion (35), PixelLab (25).

The stump monster. This one is between SpriteForge and Retro Diffusion: two very different takes on the same request. PixelLab's is messy and scuffed.

The stump monster from each tool. SpriteForge: a brown stump with a dark hollow face, two pale eyes and a few leaves on top, 8 colours. Retro Diffusion: a wide brown stump creature with orange eyes and mossy shoulders, 31 colours. PixelLab: a mottled dark green and brown figure, 41 colours
The stump monster, 16×16. Left to right: SpriteForge (8 colours), Retro Diffusion (31), PixelLab (41).

The boss. Same request: a stag spirit with a skull face. The two diffusion models drew almost the same animal. My guess is they were trained on a similar set of images. SpriteForge drew something of its own.

The boss from each tool. SpriteForge: a pale stag skull with broad antlers and orange eyes on a wide teal body with an orange glow at the chest, 13 colours. Retro Diffusion: a standing stag with branching antlers and a skull face, in dark teal, 36 colours. PixelLab: a very similar standing stag with branching antlers and a skull face, 51 colours
The boss, 32×32. Left to right: SpriteForge (13 colours), Retro Diffusion (36), PixelLab (51).

Trees, rocks and bushes. PixelLab put snow on the tree, which nobody asked for.

The pine tree, the rock and the bush from each tool. SpriteForge: a dark green pine, a grey rock with moss and a light green bush. Retro Diffusion: a teal pine, a grey rock with a white rim and a dark green bush. PixelLab: a pine covered in snow, a mottled mossy rock and a teal bush
Pine tree (32×32), rock and bush. Columns, left to right: SpriteForge, Retro Diffusion, PixelLab.

The campfire, the arrow and the spark. The arrow was asked for flying right. PixelLab's points up and to the right.

The campfire, the arrow and the spark from each tool. SpriteForge: a fire on a ring of stones, an arrow pointing right and a four-pointed spark. Retro Diffusion: a small fire on stones, a short shape with a bright tip pointing right and a small spark. PixelLab: a fire on grey stones, an arrow pointing up and to the right and a spark with stray pixels around it
Campfire, arrow and spark, 16×16. Columns, left to right: SpriteForge, Retro Diffusion, PixelLab.

Then the ground. Retro Diffusion was asked for night grass and delivered grey stone.

The ground tiles from each tool on the same test map, a ring of one terrain around a patch of another. SpriteForge: dark green grass and brown dirt with a dark line between them, 8 colours. Retro Diffusion: grey stone and orange-brown dirt, 23 colours. PixelLab: teal grass and dark brown dirt with a rounded dark blue edge, 42 colours
The ground tiles on a test map. Left to right: SpriteForge (8 colours), Retro Diffusion (23), PixelLab (42).

PixelLab has decent-looking tile sets, but does not really have the ability to create patterns that go beyond an individual tile. Diffusion services either mask this inability by offering tiles that are close to a solid colour, or straight up deliver stamp tiles where the seam is clearly visible.

One plain ground tile from Retro Diffusion and one from PixelLab, each repeated six across and four down, with thin lines on the tile borders. Retro Diffusion: grey stone with orange flecks, the same marks in every copy; the note under it reads: one tile stamped over and over: each copy shows. PixelLab: an almost even teal green; the note under it reads: close to one flat colour
One plain ground tile, repeated. Left: Retro Diffusion. Right: PixelLab. The thin lines are the tile borders.

SpriteForge can create true auto tile sets where a pattern is drawn across the tiles.

Two SpriteForge tiles, each repeated six across and four down, with thin lines on the tile borders. Gravel, with the note: an extra tile from this test (not the game's ground). Cobblestone, with the note: an example from spriteforge.tech. In both, the stones carry on across the tile borders
SpriteForge: the pattern runs across the tiles. Left: gravel, an extra tile from this test (not the game's ground). Right: cobblestone, an example from spriteforge.tech.

Overall, SpriteForge's sprites are cleaner and less noisy, and to me they look more like something a person made. They also don't have that familiar AI look the other two share.

2. Palette size

Second comparison: palette size.

An LLM can draw inside a palette. Across all 15 sprites, SpriteForge used 78 colours. Retro Diffusion used 396. PixelLab, 256.

The colours used across the 15 sprites, shown as rows of swatches: SpriteForge 78 colours, Retro Diffusion 396 colours, PixelLab 256 colours
Colours used across the 15 sprites: SpriteForge 78, Retro Diffusion 396, PixelLab 256.

The boss alone: 13 colours, against 36 and 51.

You could snap those to a palette afterwards. It could work, but it further drowns any artistic vision the diffusion model never had in the first place.

3. The overall look

Third comparison: how it all fits together in the game. Same code, same play-through, three sets of art.

Everything SpriteForge drew for the game: ranger, slime, bat, wolf, stump monster, rock, bush, campfire, arrow, spark, heart, the boss, a green pine tree, a small spark, a small heart, the ranger's walk frames, and the ground tiles on a test map: dark green grass around brown dirt
SpriteForge: everything it drew for the game.
Everything Retro Diffusion drew for the game: ranger, slime, bat, wolf, stump monster, rock, bush, campfire, arrow, spark, heart, the boss, a teal pine tree, a small spark, a small heart, the ranger's walk frames, and the ground tiles on a test map: grey stone around orange-brown dirt
Retro Diffusion: everything it drew for the game.
Everything PixelLab drew for the game: ranger, slime, bat, wolf, stump monster, rock, bush, campfire, arrow, spark, heart, the boss, a pine tree covered in snow, a small spark, a small heart, the ranger's walk frames, and the ground tiles on a test map: teal grass around dark brown dirt
PixelLab: everything it drew for the game.

PixelLab's version has snowy trees in a forest with no snow. Retro Diffusion's forest floor is stone.

A diffusion model doesn't know what your game is. Every sprite is a new roll.

With SpriteForge you describe your game once, in a project style and a project description, and every request is drawn with that in mind.

The project every SpriteForge request was drawn in. Project description: Cinderwatch: a top-down night survival game. A little forest ranger defends a campfire in a dark forest clearing while monsters come out of the dark in waves. 16 px sprites on 16 px tiles, drawn over very dark night ground (#141a22 dark blue-green); every sprite must read clearly on that dark background. Project style: 16-bit night forest, bold readable silhouettes, dark muted palette: deep teal greens, cold slate blues and near-black shadows, with small warm campfire orange and ember gold accents, no dithering. Light: top-left. Outline: dark-tinted
Described once: the project every SpriteForge request was drawn in.

You can also hand it different references for style, subject and for shading, and the model understands what each one is for.

References: pictures handed to the artist with a request. The SpriteForge ranger and pine tree, each marked as used as a style reference in this test, beside the three kinds of reference: Style, copy the look. Subject, draw this thing. Shading, light it like this. Each reference is marked with what it is for
References: pictures handed to the artist with a request, each marked with what it is for.

4. The cost

Fourth comparison: the cost. And here, SpriteForge clearly loses.

A 16×16 sprite is about 24 cents on SpriteForge when using Fable 5.2 as the artist, and 18 on Retro Diffusion. Comparable.

But a 32×32 sprite is about 83 cents, against the same 18.

That's because an LLM's work grows with the number of pixels. 32×32 has four times as many pixels as 16×16.

For a diffusion model the canvas size barely matters, since it is scaling down from a much bigger picture anyway.

WhatSpriteForge (Fable 5.2)Retro DiffusionPixelLab
16×16 spriteabout $0.24$0.18under $0.01
32×32 spriteabout $0.83$0.18about $0.03
4-frame walkabout $1.12$0.14about $0.02
Ground tile setabout $0.56$0.10under $0.01
The whole game's art$6.58$2.94about $0.16

SpriteForge and Retro Diffusion: pay-as-you-go prices. PixelLab: a share of its $12 a month plan (2,000 generations). Prices are what each service showed in mid-November 2026.

The whole game's art cost $6.58 on SpriteForge, $2.94 on Retro Diffusion, and about 16 cents' worth of PixelLab's $12 monthly plan.

Retro Diffusion also sells monthly plans that roughly halve its price. We can't match offers like that. Our margins are already non-existent.

Diffusion models mimic the result. SpriteForge goes through the process of making the image. You can feel that in the price.

The result

So. This was not the landslide victory for SpriteForge I was hoping for. It's a mixed bag.

I'm confident in the quality at 16×16 and 24×24. But the spatial reasoning that bigger sprites need is not quite where I want it to be in today's LLM models.

Gacha Dungeon

There's one more thing a test like this can't show: what happens over a whole game.

With a diffusion model, the look drifts. It can't understand your game or your style, so the hundredth sprite doesn't match the first.

SpriteForge was built for my own game: Gacha Dungeon, a large RPG that's still in development. Its main resolution is 16×16.

Around 99% of its sprites were made with SpriteForge. What that looks like is in the video, and in the demo you can play here.

The good news for SpriteForge: the drawings will get better as new models get stronger at spatial reasoning. And the price will come down as they get cheaper to run.

Which game art did you like the best?

Try SpriteForge

Free credit to start, no card.

All posts · Home